I would like to thank Fitzy and Wippa for the opportunity to write the following paragraph.
Bill Shorten was supposedly pandering to young voters this morning. Meandering through a disstrack, slandering Pine and Abbott, his boring perception shattering with every staggering swaggering clapback. Accused of manufacturing and pampering, presenting himself in an unflattering light. Is that the media panicking or capturing something I cannot see? This is what I’m wondering sitting here pondering after watching Bill and Ray Hadley on Fitzy and Wippa rapping.
Wordplay aside, I think my opinion is pretty clear. What Bill did was a brilliant move on his part and I’m 23 so I’d like to pretend that I can, kind of somewhat potentially, maybe, be a kind of “authority” on matters of young people.
Labor needs the young vote and in reality SOMEBODY needs the young vote, but how do you attract young people when all the stats tell you we are apathetic.
We are a generation who have only ever known pandering and advertising in a world where we can pick and choose what content we would like to see and what content we would not like to see. In general we can see through a lot of “bullshit”, we’re used to it, which makes us an incredibly difficult demographic for advertisers but even harder for politicians.
The argument online is that in attempting to interest and attract youth, Shorten has ruined his chances at getting the young vote but I highly disagree.
What I saw was a multi level approach that really understood it’s target publics. Shorten’s rap itself (you know the word bit) was clever enough to be funny to those who are politically aware, age aside. My favourite line for example was “”Will I rap again? it's anyone's guess. But there's more chance of Tony Abbott voting Yes”. The fact that he quite literally dabbed on the haters and participated in the rap battle at all, satisfies the young people who are entertained by the disstrack alone. The casual, almost amatuer, nature of the “rap battle” and the implication that it could be a clapback to PM Turnbul on The Project is what tips it over the edge from pandering and sad to funny and entertaining.
I’m not alone in thinking this was a clever move for Bill either. My anecdata (talking to friends my age) supports my conclusion but so does the hundreds of comments on facebook (BuzzFeed Oz Politics and Fitzy and Wippa) as of writing this. Comments vary from being mad that they aren’t mad their taxes paid for this to this video winning their vote (and a lot of cringe at the dab).
People were saying that what PM Malcolm Turnbull did on The Project (if you could even call that a rap) was better than what Shorten did, especially regarding keeping the interest of young people. I watched Malcolm on The Project and I found his behaviour offensive.
I do not for one second believe he actually listened to Tupac, he sounded like your grandpa unironically quoting a meme to sound cool but the meme is irrelevant now purely because he thinks he’s cool saying it.
Even worse, he was rude and dismissive to Waleed who -unlike Turnbull- was actually professionally doing his job. It felt like somebody told him that young people are apathetic and sick and tired of the debate, so he behaved just like that to be ‘one of us’. People talking about politics and real issues were such “downers”. I assume the aim was for us young people to see that or hear about it on the grapevine and say “look guys, he’s just like us, he too doesn’t give a shit”. But instead it was offensive and annoying.
Bill however, behaved like that cool grandpa or uncle at the barbeque who sits with the youngens and jokes with us and laughs at himself trying to dab but we’re all welcoming of him because he’s smart and also able to laugh at himself (the kind of Grandpa I imagine my own Dad will become one day).
So regarding the Turnbull vs Shorten ‘attract young adults’ rap, Shorten wins hands down though I am not opposed to a clapback from Turnbull, in fact I’d encourage it.
In the Fitzy and Wippa video alone though, it is CLEAR to see why Bill wins. He drops the mic, lets his rap speak for itself and dabs on the haters while Ray Hadley shows up in a ridiculous outfit looking like a caricature of a 90’s rapper.
If Bill showed up looking like Ray, then I would 100% agree with the media and folks on the internet criticising Bill, but he didn’t and he was even shown in a direct comparison with the former.
It is more important to young voters that they can place Bill in their view of life, that he is relevant to them and what matters to them. He needs to be daggy ol’ uncle Bill who you can laugh with but also have deep conversations with, ask for advice, after everybody at the barbeque has gone home.
The young people who are apathetic to politics will always be apathetic to politics but it doesn’t mean they are apathetic to issues. I think this is a good first step in showing that we are at least on their radar and judging by the comments BY young people, apathetic and politically inclined, he’s hit both targets.
Keep dabbing on the haters Bill but can you also, like, please go back to doing your job. kthx.
by Caitlin Mary Neate
I like to think I don't exclusively talk nonsense...
Currently studying Communications Majors Journalism and PR