NOT Left or Right, Seriously NOT ALP, LIB or Green. Just a Punter... more

23 Jan 2014

$200 Marriage Counselling voucher is offensive & smells to me

Social Media:   
Kevin Andrews Register of Interests 13. Membership of any organisation where a conflict of interest with a Member's public duties could foreseeably arise or be seen to arise http://www.openaustralia.org/regmem/scan/register_interests_10014.pdf

Reading  the news this morning and coming across “Federal Government offers newlyweds $200 voucher to attend marriage counselling” I nearly choked on my coffee, I thought when that was suggested prior to the election it was just a dodgy feel-good brain fart to make the Australian Christian Lobby & other God Squad groups feel confident about backing the Liberals.  Sadly, no, looks like Kevin Andrew’s is going ahead with it.

If that didn’t make me cranky enough, this tweet from the lovely Pattie pushed me over the edge:

I could not believe that even with the dodgy mates who have been employed recently, see recent rant “Why is a cop held to a higher standard of integrity than an MP?”, surely this was just a coincidence?  Off I went googling...

What did I find.  Well, a 'Whois Record lookup' of MarriageEducation.com.au shows the registrant contact as "Margaret Andrews".  But hey, pretty common name, may not be Social Services Minister Kevin Andrews (who is implementing this program) wife?

So next step, thought I would have a look at the honourable MP’s Register of Interests, you can download the pdf 'here', though I have screenshot the relevant item in the graphic above.  I could be wrong, but reckon the chances that Margaret Andrews of Marriage Education Programme Inc. is the same Margaret Andrews who is Kevin Andrew’s wife and it is just a ‘coincidence’ that Marriage Education Programme Inc. is also on this register?  

I won’t even get into why the hell an organisation that is charging $240 a chat for a Marriage Preparation Course can be of a charitable status?  Though I suppose I should not be surprised as many social services over the past decade or so seem to have been taken over by religious organisations.  Not that the website for Marriage Education Programme Inc. really screams ‘Catholic’?

Marriage Education Programme Inc.: ABN: 28481381568: Tax Status: GST Concession FBT Rebate Income Tax Exemption: Charity Type: Charitable Institution: Org Type: Other Incorporated Entity

Anyhow, charity or not, just the fact that Mr Andrew’s is implementing a policy that his wife is directly going to benefit from has to be a conflict, in fact, he belonging to the Australian Catholic Marriage & Family Council has to be a conflict?  It really is not the done thing to put in place a Government policy that directly benefits your ‘religion’ and personal area of interest in that religion?

We have only just recently been told we need a review of Welfare, it is unsustainable...

When there are single parents who are at this very moment stressing and feeling ashamed that their children may be going back to school with holes in their shoes but they can’t afford to replace, yet $200 (which would well & truly pay for those shoes) is going to newly-weds, who are probably going to spend a fortune on a wedding bash anyhow?  That to me is just highly offensive.   To see that Kevin Andrew’s wife & his religious interest could possibly benefit at the expense of more worthy people is beyond offensive :(

Before anyone screams at me, I was raised a Catholic, first marriage (didn't last long) was in a Catholic church so know that it is COMPULSORY to have these courses/classes before the priest will marry you.  Yet, if you happen to get tossed against a wall by your husband, Catholic church is not too interested, in fact, will encourage you to try to "work it out" with your husband (yeah right...) AND should you be lucky enough to find a man who will treat you with respect, you cannot get your abusive marriage anulled?

Sooo...  Let's see what better uses there could be for the $20 million for this trial?  School shoes for kids on the dodgy newstart payment?  Shelters or Support for Victims of Domestic Violence?  Give me your suggestions in the comments below, I can think of heaps!

But hey, what would I know, I am sure we will find out that this is all perfectly legitimate and I am just a dumb punter who doesn't think this passes the pub poll test...
Noely 

PS: If you are interested in learning a bit more about the Andrews, this piece by Benjamin Law from 2010 is interesting "Up close and personal with Margaret Andrews" - thanks @johnnybridge2 for bringing this blast from the past to my attention :)

NOTE: Wendy below has raised "Kevin Andrews' most recent declaration (lodged in December 2013) says that while his wife is still a marriage educator, he and she have resigned as members of Marriage Education Program Inc." I have not been able to find a 2013 Register of Interests, though if I do I will amend of course, or better yet, hopefully a Journalist will actually look at this issue properly.  Though having said that, this 'idea' of $200 vouchers was floated prior to the election, so IF Mr & Mrs Andrews did resign, we would need to see if those dates of resignation were prior to Mr Andrews being re-elected & being put into the Social Services portfolio?  If the resignation has happened after that appointment, then it is really just clearing the decks to look appropriate? :(

UPDATE 9.05am: clearing decks it is judging by latest "declaration" signed 09 Dec 2013 AFTER Mr Andrews has taken on the Social Services portfolio, make of that what you will :(
Please be aware that the pdf may not come up in all browsers, I had an awful time with it until I put the URL into an older version than I normally use of Internet Explorer

Thanks to Susan (@SElizaP) for pointing out that Mr & Mrs Andrews co-founded the Marriage Education Programme in 1980  so obviously a long held belief in Marriage Counselling.  Lovely that Mr Andrews can now use his position as the Social Services Minister to ensure these groups like the Australian Catholic Marriage and Family Council can carry on with this $200 Wedding Voucher to be used for 'Counselling'? 
The Hon Kevin Andrews MP - some useful background info http://tasmaniantimes.com/images/uploads/Andrews.pdf … he & his wife on board of...http://www.fightpp.org/  which is a bit of a worry?
Another blast from the past courtesy of Dr Sally Cockburn (@DrSallyCockburn) "Andrews in radical group that boycotts Disney" Ladies & Gents, this is your Minister for Social Services?
Mr & Mrs Andrews may have resigned from Marriage Education Programme Inc. on the 9th of December 2013 (see above), though it seems this 'organisation' is still happy to promote the purchase of Mr Andrews book “Maybe 'I Do': Modern Marriage and the Pursuit of Happiness”?
23 Jan 2013 "#CashVows - Newlyweds $200 Marriage Counselling Voucher" Written by David Marler - Fairfax journalist Jonathan Swan reports there is no conflict of interest as Margaret Andrews has quit her job.
Noely: "That would obviously be correct that there is no direct conflict as Mrs Andrew's has quit her job (as we saw on the register of interests above) though this may not be a direct monetary benefit it still 'smells'.  I am sure if the wider public were aware of exactly how this policy was pushing a particular barrow of Mr & Mrs Andrews that they have held for decades & advocated for strongly, not to mention I am sure they get support from these Catholic communities, I am not so sure it would fly as legit, it would look more like using public funds to to prop up a niche 'Ideological' stance a politician has."

Consider...

Thank you Helen Davidson "My marriage doesn't need government help. Give $200 to someone who does" - this is a seriously good piece in the guardian, please read.
Thank you to Jason Tin (@jasonthetin) of the Courier Mail for raising this issue in the media "Kevin Andrews has no problem with government marriage counselling handouts because his wife is `no longer a marriage educator'"

26 Jan 2014 Update: Let's ramp up the offensive...  Mrs Margaret Andrews has received an OAM (Medal of the Order of Australia) for "For service to the Catholic Church in Australia through a range of marriage education programs." make of that what you will?

Marriage graphic courtesy of the lovely & talented Anita who is sadly not on Twitter, but still shares :)

Social Media:   

If you are having an issue on Tablets leaving a comment, please "sign in" or "register" before making a comment, or email Noely directly and she will load it for you.

comments powered by Disqus

Latest Comments

Rants direct to your Inbox

Sign up below to be kept in the loop for new articles


First
Last
*
*
Please fill the text in this image in the field below to assist us in eliminating spam
 

Pandora Initiative

"I am humbled the NLA Pandora initiative, whose mission is 'Preserving and Accessing Networked Documentary Resources of Australia' has chosen to archive this site." Did you know you may be able to find on Pandora things which have been subsequently deleted. For example Mr Abbott's past speeches which were deleted once he became PM can be found here: http://pandora.nla.gov.au/tep/22487

Topical Media Reports

  • Please show your appreciation by following and supporting @lynlinking who works very hard to disseminate both blog posts & relevant media reports on a daily basis :)